/* Google Analytics Code asynchronous */

Saturday, April 26, 2008

SuperDay+3: Logan's Run

Looking at the tables below, you see why dragging the race out is just like making Obama do Logan's Run.

To illustrate, with detail, why all that is left to decide is a margin of defeat for Hillary, start with a table of the upcoming races.

The table below has 411 pledged delegates remaining (the prior estimate has 408), good enough for government work.

Table 1. Remaining race prizes. Delegates breakout from Green Papers. "Supers" breakdown from the AP.

RaceTotal DelegatesTotal PledgedTotal "Supers"Clinton SupersObama SupersRest
Guam945203
Indiana84759531
North.Carolina134115192611
West Virginia392811326
Kentucky60519315
Oregon655213229
PuertoRico63558332
Montana24168035
South Dakota23158062
GRAND TOTAL50141190202644

Projections show how the "must do" hurdle rates for Hillary climb, even as she "wins", because the amount of race left to run shrinks and she is behind.

For this projection, it is assumed that the candidate who wins the primary takes all the "supers" that have not already declared themselves. This "winner takes all" strategy is based on the loose assumption that "supers" could be pressured to vote in the manner of their constituencies, at least those who have not already put a public face against doing so by committing aloud.

The margins of victory I've just taken from Todd at MSNBC, except for Guam and Puerto Rico, where I just made something up. As before, this assumes that all FL and MI delegates, super and plain, get apportioned by her electoral margin in each state.

You can see that, to catch up, Hillary already needs a 35% spread among delegates to be won through (expensive) campaigning. This will jump to 71% in just 10 days. This is true, even if she ekes out a small margin of victory in Indiana.

All the way to the end of the race, Obama has room to spare.

Expanding the pool to her of all potential delegates to be garnered, both super and pledged, you can see that even big wins in KY, WV, and Puerto Rico do not help her, for the same reason - just a bigger piece of a pie that his shrinking faster than she is winning. At the end, she would need 56%, more than half, of the yet undeclared "supers". It seems unlikely, even in a fight, she would get that level of support from within the party, yes?

Update: Table 2 has been superseded. Find the first update here.

Table 2. A projections "winner takes all" of the remaining, undeclared "supers" along the way. If they win the race in the state, they get all the supers who have not declared as of today's AP tally. Starting point assumes Obama "gives" Clinton delegates in FL, MI in proportion to her vote in those states.


Projection1: Winner takes all remaining State supersDays

Margin Clinton over ObamaClinton Net Pickup (Loss) PledgedClinton Net Pickup (Loss) SupersObama Lead / (Trail)Clinton Must Do Margin All LeftObama Pledged Lead / (Trail)Clinton Must Do Margin Among Remaining Pledged
Pennsylvania-3 days


11917%14335%
Guam7 days2%0311617%14335%
Indiana10 days2%1111419%14243%
North Carolina10 days-10%-11-1113629%15371%
West Virginia17 days20%6612429%14778%
Kentucky24 days20%11510829%13699%
Oregon24 days-10%-6-912339%142shutout
Puerto Rico36 days20%11211044%131shutout
Montana38 days-10%-2-511751%133shutout
South Dakota38 days-10%-1-212056%134
n.m.