Post-Oscar special:
Monday, March 8, 2010
Has Iran consolidated influence on Iraq Shiite Islamic Parties?, Part II

Juan Cole, answer, "yes":
...
But now the Friday prayers preacher of Najaf is denouncing global arrogance and openly calling Iraq a colonized country that must regain its independence.
It's not clear the strategic ambitions the "religious parties", of the non-Da'wa block (non-Maliki). Among them might be a veto power, within the government, similar to a "guardianship". (Ostensibly, they are just for kicking out the U.S. as soon as possible).
Cole outlines two options:
He thinks the Iran alliance is the odds on bet. Why? He thinks the Kurds, to whatever degree fragmented (but not "unraveled") after the current elections, would not ally with a "Sunni dominated" block. Also, he doesn't think that the alternative to the status quo will pull enough votes to catalyze a "radical change".
If he's right, then the U.S. taxpayer will have paid a trillion dollars and 4,380 lives ... to achieve this culmination of Cheney-Rumsfeld-Perle vision for a new Iraq, at least for the foreseeable future, an Iraq not facing away from the tyranny in Iran but suckling from it, to some uneasy degree.
Sunday, March 7, 2010
The things we do for Oscar
Das Weisse Band was good, but so long that I felt I was in a German language immersion experience.
Otherwise, we're prepared, except for Precious, which was missed and didn't get any local re-airing in the run-up to the Big Day.
Has Iran consolidated influence on Iraq Shiite Islamic Parties?
March 7th, 2010, may be the day that highlights how much the future of Iraq lies with Iran, with the influence that Iran has gained over Iraq's religious Shia parties.
background
Not know squat about the history of Iraqi internal politics, but a few names of the key players? Who can blame you, it's a maze!
Here is my (non-expert) shorthand, for you.
Sectarianism, as it has developed (including pre-invasion positioning!), has played into Iranian hands, primarily by consolidating Iranian influence among the Shiite Islamic political parties.
- First, the constitution of 2005 apparently pushes sectarianism by apportionment structures that prevent strong central government, i.e. that force a national power-sharing. With the imminent withdrawal of the U.S., there seems to be little leverage to get the constitution to evolve, to reflect possibilities for Iraq rather than yesterdays irreconcilable realities. As I understand it - and I could be wrong - it is a kind of structural bias that doesn't bode well, that tips the playing field.
- Second, in a classic short-term versus long-term bind, the U.S. (and the Kurds) had a role in supporting the rise of the pro-Iranian SCIRI (now just 'SICI') and putting down the pro-national Sadrists. Now, Sadr's nationalist fire is almost completely neutralized by Iran: he lives there and cannot return home, under threat of a warrant for his arrest.
- Third, the most pro-Iranian coalition has been successful in politicizing for potential electoral gain the sectarian issue of de-baathification, while simultaneously cutting out many centrists/secularists from any political roles. [We know it has worked but not by how much, because the votes aren't in, yet.]
- Forth, the Iranian influence on the Iraqi National Alliance (the Watani list or INA or NIA) appears to be consolidated. The Iranian-elements have moved in on the coalition's second-tier leadership roles and so forth and the party's creed has been aligned to mimic Iranian concepts, even dropping explicit reference to Najef... The coordination-consultation with Tehran, not just Najef, is obvious and profound. The shove out of the main Daawa party from the coalition last year, 'purifies' and consolidates.
The Daawa party (the main part of Nouri al-Malaki's new 'State of Law' coalition), with a very long history in Iraqi politics and no philosophical ally of the Iranian Revolution, appears to be ... suffering the burdens of governance, in a situation that is rife with non-cooperation, corruption, and a long list of problems. It's also been fractured by political rivalries. However, it gained support in 2009 elections, but the broader coalition that brought it to power fractured under Iranian 'supervision' last year, probably because of a reach-out for Sunni participation, for a true 'national coalition'.
The relatively secularist alternatives, the Iraqiyya list or National Movement (includes Iyad Allawi's group), is small, smaller than I realized, but has polled well, recently, despite being saddled with baggage related to the invasion and the 'battle for Fallujah'.
Separately, the Kurdish alliances are following the pattern of increased fragmentation, with four coalitions now contesting, rather than the big two (PUK and PDK). I have no idea with whom the Kurdish parties would align in a new government. Relations have been strained with al-Maliki and the Kurds have natural and historical 'ties' to Iran.
I cannot add too much color on the Sunni participation or the likelihood that a Sunni bloc might join a new coalition government - offhand, it seems more like various Sunni politicians have made it to the lists of other coalition groups.
Saturday, March 6, 2010
Fascinating problems in decision making under uncertainty?
Which analysis is best, one that has access to truth or one that has access to quasi-truth?
Not clear, says someone who should know.
What is the value of inside information? One has to separate inside facts from inside analysis. There are also ways of doing analysis that do not involve understanding everyone's emotions or 'personal opinions', to the extent that those are classified.
I don't know any effort to figure out whether inside or outside methods are superior, however.
Short term deployments for long term problems
THIS IS NOT 'SEXY' OR 'KENETIC' - IGNORE AT YOUR OWN RISK
One of the more interesting proposals I've seen in a while, at least:
This year, the aid workers should be prepared to pay farmers compensation for any opium crops they are unable to harvest as a result of the fighting, and the Western coalition should help the groups develop a microcredit system.
-Joshua Foust, NYT
The microcredit system seems very clever. It seems that it might be lawful for the farmers to assign their debt obligations to someone else, so that the religious issues are skirted. Paying for opium crops has to come with strings attached - if done, it has to be done over time, not with cash, and with an eye toward gathering intel on the Taliban.
The solution to this problem seems to be "transition" in COIN-speak, but ...
This looks like part of a familiar pattern: troops move into an area, kill anyone firing a machine gun, then move on to the next, bigger target hoping they have left behind a functioning government. It’s why many communities in central Helmand have experienced three influxes of NATO forces in three years
Update: I just read somewhere that the US's official policy is not to do anything about production, but to target traffickers. If that is current, then ... USG, always a step behind...
Lawyers fight over who among them to stigmatize the most
So far, it looks like just labor lawyers will continue to be viewed as doing the devil's work.
...posted because the law is too important to be left to lawyers.
Friday, March 5, 2010
Virginia GOP Rebukes Thomas Jefferson
HUNTING SEASON IN VIRGINIA
Old Thomas Jefferson invented the phrase "separation of Church and State". He was an adamant believer that religious doctrine was an odd bedfellow with government. His views cost him dearly in his day.
On the heels of a new antigay Governor, it's come to light that Old Dominion's throwback AG has written a letter to state universities, telling them that their non-discrimination policies must be scrapped, insofar as they offer policy assurances to gays and lesbians that they are not a target group.
TURN YOUR BACK ON MODERN VERSION OF 'NO IRISH NEED APPLY'
You can feel the radiant heat from these flames of bigotry and intolerance all around.
Would you want to recruit at a school that institutionalized homophobia? It's bad enough that the military does it ...
Frank Schaeffer Nails It, Again
Someone could make something feature length from Frank Schaeffer's appearances. I'll even leave a room to go watch him.
I continue to fail to understand why the secessionists and these militia groups are not of greater concern, politically speaking.
This is the time for the Left to find its voice on Patriotism, if it has any. Either that, or the country is in such bad shape that we shrug this stuff off, somehow. Can you imagine someone in the 1950s, say, proposing secessionist articles or setting up their own militia, without being denounced as communist sympathizers or worse?
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Rove, WMD and Truth & Reconciliation
As long as Rove is going to write about WMD, I'd like to just raise the same question that I have before, even if it may have been answered and I just don't know it.
Who is the classifying authority on the Iraq Survey Group (ISG) appropriation? If it was the VP, then can Biden review and release? (background)
Why?
I'd like to know how much the biggest search for nothing in the history of the world cost the U.S. taxpayer. Ad hoc reports say it is nearly $1 billion - billion. But, it would be nice to know and also to know the rationale for classification, if it was anything but shielding the Administration from public accountability.
It's not trivial. This odd secrecy occurred before the 2004 election.
Thursday, March 4, 2010
David Petraeus, For the Hour
Charlie Rose continues, putting up what is now a fascinating progression of interviews.
This last one is the best interview, IMHO.
It's wonderful that we can have dialogs like these, finally, without the rightwing bleeting on about "do you want to 'win' or not?"; "the War on Terror" (that hapless phrase); "the lessons of 9/11" and everything else that engendered the semelparous string of propositions that was strung together to keep in office a CIC and his Veep who were probably derelict for their lack of wartime prep and ended up war criminals, to boot.
What's also interesting is to watch the progression of rightwing anxiety-and-prescription. There is always *someone* who is scapegoated in such a way that 'if only not for them, we'd have our way!'. Arafat, Mutada al-Sadr, Hans Blix, the French weasels, ... right now, it is Pakistan, still. How thin.
Wheels NOT On Fire
Impossible to know whether the repeal of DADT has been buried in study or whether the study is actually a good tool for the military, to convince themselves that they can do it. It really is textbook to not make changes of this kind fiat, especially when significant resistance is anticipated.
Coming up with a solid implementation plan, that's smart. But trying to study the impact on "readiness"? No amount of study will fully settle that question, ultimately, because the question is one of leadership capability. (No implementation plan is going to survive first contact, either, but that's another issue).
The effort has political risks to the President.
Special mention to congresscritter John Flemming, R-Louisiana, who reminds the panel that the purpose of the military is to be ready for war "which we do frequently around here, as you know". Watch the awkward exchange culminating at 50:09.
(link)
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Thought for the Day
LITTLE TRUST, STINTED ECONOMIC GRWOTH
Yesterday's "War on Terror" (that hapless phrase) is today's "War on Corruption".
Some huge proportion of every article I read, these days, cannot fail to mention corruption, principally in Afghanistan, Iraq, or Pakistan.
The elections in Afghanistan and Iraq both have "corruption" as a major theme. We actually have officials who guesstimate how much of our contracting work goes to graft, bribes, or grease.
Dramatizing a *huge*, well-known problem, PBS has a documentary out about Pakistan's notorious paper schools, the ones that get funding on paper that goes into pockets elsewhere. Separately, we supposedly are paying money to Pakistan for 'police training', but our own metrics show the police to be hopelessly corrupt. It goes to the top. Even Bhutto's husband was known as "Mr. Ten Percent". [update: money flying out of Afghanistan, literally, to the gold coasters...]
DEFINING DOWN 'THE GOOD FIGHT'
Hamid Karzai, after pledging to "fight corruption", recently gave himself control over the Afghani equivalent of the FEC. Was that a blow for justice (a routing of trouble makers) or a blow for non-accountability? At some point, the structure of the government becomes indefensible, threatening to compound any corruption problems, right? Our hopes for the women of Afghanistan have been scuttled by the political dynamics and expediency of the conflict there.
In general, we've typically failed ourselves, trying to support the "less evil" option, during the cold war, no?
At a minimum, this presents a problem for modern COIN doctrine. What if the population has two choices, neither of which they want to fight for? I'm not sure there is that level of apathy or disaffection, but ...
Pay for the Wars
CAN LIBERAL PUNDITS SET AN AGENDA, RATHER THAN JUST RESPOND?Alan K. Simpson and Erskine Bowles are an okay start.
The President needs to appoint an economist who knows how FDR and Truman paid down the war debt.
Second, he needs someone who is unorthodox on trade policy, who understands that we have to boost national savings and that we can use the tax code to do it (and not by making Roth conversions available to the wealthy, as did Bush et. al. - d'oh!).
Monday, March 1, 2010
Political Ascendancy, Fundie Sorority Chapter
Robert P. George, NOM booster and implacable loudmouth behind various "Declarations", must be throwing himself against the walls today.
Check out this title from the New York Times, Op-Ed: Learning From the Sin of Sodom
Oh, my, oh my:
nooooooo!:
Hmm. Imagine if sodomy laws could be used to punish the stingy, unconcerned rich!
God is Great
It's a drag race, in Kirkuk, Iraqi-style:
The NYT, in typical hysteria over everything in the mideast. !!! - !!!, OMG!!!
We sometimes don't realize just how much conflict is permissible, in some places. I wouldn't overstress that, because there are equally powerful forces for "order". But it does sometimes seem as though our standards for what is shocking, for good or ill, are our own...


