/* Google Analytics Code asynchronous */

Friday, March 5, 2010

Frank Schaeffer Nails It, Again

Someone could make something feature length from Frank Schaeffer's appearances. I'll even leave a room to go watch him.

I continue to fail to understand why the secessionists and these militia groups are not of greater concern, politically speaking.

This is the time for the Left to find its voice on Patriotism, if it has any. Either that, or the country is in such bad shape that we shrug this stuff off, somehow. Can you imagine someone in the 1950s, say, proposing secessionist articles or setting up their own militia, without being denounced as communist sympathizers or worse?

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Rove, WMD and Truth & Reconciliation

As long as Rove is going to write about WMD, I'd like to just raise the same question that I have before, even if it may have been answered and I just don't know it.

Who is the classifying authority on the Iraq Survey Group (ISG) appropriation? If it was the VP, then can Biden review and release? (background)

Why?

I'd like to know how much the biggest search for nothing in the history of the world cost the U.S. taxpayer. Ad hoc reports say it is nearly $1 billion - billion. But, it would be nice to know and also to know the rationale for classification, if it was anything but shielding the Administration from public accountability.

It's not trivial. This odd secrecy occurred before the 2004 election.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

David Petraeus, For the Hour


Charlie Rose continues, putting up what is now a fascinating progression of interviews.

This last one is the best interview, IMHO.

It's wonderful that we can have dialogs like these, finally, without the rightwing bleeting on about "do you want to 'win' or not?"; "the War on Terror" (that hapless phrase); "the lessons of 9/11" and everything else that engendered the semelparous string of propositions that was strung together to keep in office a CIC and his Veep who were probably derelict for their lack of wartime prep and ended up war criminals, to boot.

What's also interesting is to watch the progression of rightwing anxiety-and-prescription. There is always *someone* who is scapegoated in such a way that 'if only not for them, we'd have our way!'. Arafat, Mutada al-Sadr, Hans Blix, the French weasels, ... right now, it is Pakistan, still. How thin.

Wheels NOT On Fire

Impossible to know whether the repeal of DADT has been buried in study or whether the study is actually a good tool for the military, to convince themselves that they can do it. It really is textbook to not make changes of this kind fiat, especially when significant resistance is anticipated.

Coming up with a solid implementation plan, that's smart. But trying to study the impact on "readiness"? No amount of study will fully settle that question, ultimately, because the question is one of leadership capability. (No implementation plan is going to survive first contact, either, but that's another issue).

The effort has political risks to the President.

Special mention to congresscritter John Flemming, R-Louisiana, who reminds the panel that the purpose of the military is to be ready for war "which we do frequently around here, as you know". Watch the awkward exchange culminating at 50:09.

(link)

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Thought for the Day


LITTLE TRUST, STINTED ECONOMIC GRWOTH

Yesterday's "War on Terror" (that hapless phrase) is today's "War on Corruption".

Some huge proportion of every article I read, these days, cannot fail to mention corruption, principally in Afghanistan, Iraq, or Pakistan.

The elections in Afghanistan and Iraq both have "corruption" as a major theme. We actually have officials who guesstimate how much of our contracting work goes to graft, bribes, or grease.

Dramatizing a *huge*, well-known problem, PBS has a documentary out about Pakistan's notorious paper schools, the ones that get funding on paper that goes into pockets elsewhere. Separately, we supposedly are paying money to Pakistan for 'police training', but our own metrics show the police to be hopelessly corrupt. It goes to the top. Even Bhutto's husband was known as "Mr. Ten Percent". [update: money flying out of Afghanistan, literally, to the gold coasters...]

DEFINING DOWN 'THE GOOD FIGHT'

Hamid Karzai, after pledging to "fight corruption", recently gave himself control over the Afghani equivalent of the FEC. Was that a blow for justice (a routing of trouble makers) or a blow for non-accountability? At some point, the structure of the government becomes indefensible, threatening to compound any corruption problems, right? Our hopes for the women of Afghanistan have been scuttled by the political dynamics and expediency of the conflict there.

In general, we've typically failed ourselves, trying to support the "less evil" option, during the cold war, no?

At a minimum, this presents a problem for modern COIN doctrine. What if the population has two choices, neither of which they want to fight for? I'm not sure there is that level of apathy or disaffection, but ...

Pay for the Wars

CAN LIBERAL PUNDITS SET AN AGENDA, RATHER THAN JUST RESPOND?

Alan K. Simpson and Erskine Bowles are an okay start.

The President needs to appoint an economist who knows how FDR and Truman paid down the war debt.

The President needs to appoint an economist who knows how FDR and Truman paid down the war debt.
We'll have plenty of it to consider and the most aggressive techniques have to be on the table, if there is a "compromise" to be found.

Second, he needs someone who is unorthodox on trade policy, who understands that we have to boost national savings and that we can use the tax code to do it (and not by making Roth conversions available to the wealthy, as did Bush et. al. - d'oh!).

Monday, March 1, 2010

Political Ascendancy, Fundie Sorority Chapter

Robert P. George, NOM booster and implacable loudmouth behind various "Declarations", must be throwing himself against the walls today.

Check out this title from the New York Times, Op-Ed: Learning From the Sin of Sodom

Oh, my, oh my:

A growing number of conservative Christians are explicitly and self-critically acknowledging that to be “pro-life” must mean more than opposing abortion.


nooooooo!:

In one striking passage, Mr. Stearns quotes the prophet Ezekiel as saying that the great sin of the people of Sodom wasn’t so much that they were promiscuous or gay as that they were “arrogant, overfed and unconcerned; they did not help the poor and needy.” (Ezekiel 16:49.)

Hmm. Imagine if sodomy laws could be used to punish the stingy, unconcerned rich!

God is Great

It's a drag race, in Kirkuk, Iraqi-style:

Early in the campaign, the Kirkuk governor met with all the political parties, as well as the U.S. military, and urged them to tone down fiery rhetoric and put an end to the high-speed political car rallies, which sometimes saw rivals trying to run each other off the road.


The NYT, in typical hysteria over everything in the mideast. !!! - !!!, OMG!!!

We sometimes don't realize just how much conflict is permissible, in some places. I wouldn't overstress that, because there are equally powerful forces for "order". But it does sometimes seem as though our standards for what is shocking, for good or ill, are our own...

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Understanding Theory

Theory is theory is a theory.

-Yours Truly


What Darwin Got Wrong

According to Darwin, traits of creatures are selected for their contribution to fitness [likelihood to survive]. But how do you distinguish a trait that is selected for from one that comes along with it? There are a lot of interesting structures in creatures that have nothing to do with fitness.

Some variants in selection are clearly environmental. If you can’t store water you’ll do worse in a dry environment than if you can. But suppose that having a high ability to carry a lot of water is correlated for genetic reasons with skin color. How do you decide which trait is selected for by environmental factors and which one is just attached to it? There isn’t anything in the Darwinist picture that allows you to answer that question.

....

What the genetics has come to show is that traits are not independent, but complexly interconnected, and a lot of the effect that the environment has on an organism’s evolution depends on what organism it is.


Update: one should take care, as I haven't done above, to separate the phenomenon of common ancestry from the theory of the mechanisms by which evolutionary biological changes take place. It should go without saying, but still...

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Gingrich is no Think Tank

When it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, ...it's a duck.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Commandant Queeg?

“My personal opinion is that unless we can strip away the emotion, agenda and politics and ask [whether] we somehow enhance the war-fighting of the United States Marine Corps by allowing homosexuals to openly serve, then we haven’t addressed it from the correct perspective,”

-Gen James T. Conway, Commandant U.S. Marine Corps, 2/25/10




He's the one who is clouded by emotion. His problem is easy to solve: As long as there is potentially one gay or lesbian solider, sailor, marine, or airman who is better than some lazy, irascible nongay one, it is a force multiplier.

Second, we've always drafted gay and lesbian citizens and could do so today. No one gay has the right to a discharge. This is part of the core bullshit at the heart of this policy (and that's why it's not a 'civil rights' issue, but a bullshit issue, for me).




“Enforced silence has led to collective amnesia about the patriotic service and courageous sacrifices of gay and lesbian troops,” said Dr. Steve Estes, guest curator of “Out Ranks.” “This exhibit tells the stories of some of our military’s most exceptional servicemembers during the most pivotal times in our country’s history.” (link)


Third, we can ask other questions, too. The purpose of the military is certainly to fight wars, but we need to 'live our values'. Integrity is key to that, clearly within the military and (hopefully) without.

Chait Dishes The Dish

A calm, collected rejoinder, very much worth the read.

One wonders if it isn't Andrew's view of Obama coupled with "simplistic view" of Israel that is the prime mover.

It remains to be seen whether Andrew is teachable on the issue.

I'm not hopeful.

One can listen, for instance, to his bile on hate crimes via C-span, recorded just last week, even, a disjoint and disconnected series of pronouncements, including a call for bigots to "Bring it on!". *sigh*

In his last post in his defense-against-the-dark-arts series, he was still wearing his willingness to publish ahead of real or conclusive science on the aptitude disparities among the races as a badge of courage, instead of a preening desire to be 'edgy'.

Israel, join the club. ...?

{Sorry, but the opposition to hate-crimes legislation, which includes the attendant issues of law enforcement, is really a Waterloo, for me; and I don't see the issues involved as left-right or staunchly conservative-progressive.}

The Real War is Not to Be Seen at the "Health Care Summit"

Following on our 'odd juxtaposition of the day', here's one snapshot, a small piece of the real conflict and the real chessboard players:

A Mouthful

I find this kind of surgical execution, however awful, to be morally superior to the collateral deaths of so many innocent children and civilians, as occurred in the Gaza war under the rules of conduct the IDF allowed. It's also morally more defensible than the US drone attacks in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

-Andrew Sullivan


Boy, that's a mouthful, isn't it. Somehow, I don't think that is going to recapture the conservative soul.

Extra-judicial murder, assassination, is a dicey business. We open the door to lowering the standard for what we judge "innocent". Indeed, we can end up with an unmoored political definition of "innocent", one that so blurs the line that the oft-seen declaration of "there are no innocents among them" comes to mind.

It also potentially surrenders the moral high ground in a high stakes game of political pressure, the struggle for legitimacy in the eyes of crucial arbiters. For instance, suppose five American soldiers were kidnapped in "retaliation" for this assassination. Is that targeting 'morally superior'? Can one condemn it?

Suppose al-qa'ida were able to kill our President or, say, our Secretary of Defense. Would we consider that 'morally superior' to a mass attack of some kind? I doubt it would feel that way. Because of the symbolism of it, we'd all feel attacked, no?

Suppose 'insurgents' in Iraq start to hang citizen "collaborators". Just because it is organized, does that render it morally superior to killing people 'by accident' or 'at random'?

The drone attacks is a different analysis, maybe...

As for Gaza, why focus on that? It seems unnecessarily narrow for a general point (perhaps this is not a general point?). In any case, a 'connected criticism' would include an answer to what Israel was supposed to do in response to rockets from Gaza, even if they weren't enormously lethal. The best greenfield answer is to remove the Hamas from leadership, right? Or, is it - let's hear the opinions of those who'd make one. Of course, one can judge the execution of the incursion on its own merits, but one risks missing the forest for the trees, in doing so.

"Basji"


I'm not liking this word that has gained currency.

I think we should be writing something like "extralegal paramilitary" or "extralegal Basiji", to emphasize the sketchy legal foundations of their actions.

In fact, I think this angle is what ought to be used by our Secretary of State, when leveling criticisms. How shameful is it that the Islamic Republic of Iran has to rely on the un-uniformed and unidentifiable to maintain/enforce its legitimacy?

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Odd Juxtaposition of the Day

Continuing our series, in what I might call context seepage due to the wide range of things that peek my interest, here's one:

"The Health Care Lobby Swarms Washington: 8 Lobbyists For Each Member Of Congress"

- HuffPo


a fundamental principal of war, mass[ing force], which dictates U.S. units employ as much combat power as possible against their enemies

- Andrew Exum


.

Iraq The Model (uh, Model Longest Term Engagement)




What's happening in Iraq?


I have not seen such a wide discrepancy in expert views since late 2005.
- Tom Ricks, 2/24/2010, NYT Op-Ed


  • Elections on March 7th. Last minute boycotts, drama, and horrible violence, etc.
  • We continue to play an important brokering role, etc., despite "overwatch" status.
  • The original, lawful power sharing rules will expire, shortly, making it easier to consolidate power. Whether that power is accepted or used wisely (e.g. with pending hydrocarbon law, etc.)?:

    In the past these issues have led to violence, and if the March elections cause tensions to resurface they may lead to conflict at a time when U.S. troops are quickly leaving the country. In following this policy the United States is taking a risk, passing responsibility for security to newly elected Iraqi officials before they may be ready to take on the challenges that lie ahead of them. Careful and constant evaluation of changing conditions is necessary to ensure that the United States withdraws from Iraq responsibly, leaving behind a government that can provide security for its people and govern effectively - not a house of cards that will fall apart at the first sign of conflict.

    -Anthony Cordesman


    You know what that means. More troops.

    [Update: Odierno requests more troops - how good am I? LOL. You can't make this stuff up. One can't help but notice that the military only made force requests through the JCS under Rumsfeld, but not under Obama.]

  • No one can say with a high degree of confidence whether the political situation is grim and getter worse, doing "well enough" or getting better.

    The practical impact of the seemingly arbitrary use of the Bremer-regent de-Baatification law in the run-up to the elections is impossible to determine. (Tom Ricks has shown a pair of very good, competing viewpoints, for instance, on his blog).

    What one is after through elections and institutions is accountability and checks-and-balances and, broadly put, the ability to deliver Justice to the people.

    In those terms, it's not clear that, in the short run, cutting out the secularists is horrible (except insofar as they prey on women and minorities, abjectly). In the long-run, cutting out secularists is a recipe for stagnation and abject conservatism, and a staff for fundamentalism. A vibrant secularist movement is vital to long-term success

  • Is the day-to-day life for civilians across the board improving or not? Are there mid-term roadbumps that will upset any current trajectory?

    Very hard to tell. People move their internal benchmarks. Even tangible progress doesn't feel like it, sometimes, as "improvements" are "taken for granted" or "accepted as 'what should have been done a long time ago'".

    Who knows, in general? Electricity output is the same as it was. Bond prices have improved. Inflation is under control.


State Department updates.
The DOD's quarterlies.