/* Google Analytics Code asynchronous */

Thursday, February 25, 2010

DADT - Smashing stereotypes

Readers will remember this long and rich collection of comments, gathered during the first few weeks of the 2010 repeal drive for DADT.

Here's an interesting story from the U.K.:

further to my last, as mincing queens were mentioned - this reminded me of a mincing queen who was well known in Bristol years ago, by the name of "Sapphire"- a black guy. Saw him many times mincing up and down Gloucester Road with an outrageous fur coat and sometimes a crown on his head,

in fact quite a popular character, bus and taxi drivers used to laugh and wave at him and exchanged good-natured banter.

Never forget the day when three aggressive "manly" straight guys who obviously didnt know him, decided to pick on him.

Most people who knew Sapphire were aware of the fact despite him being a queen, he was as hard as nails and not to be messed with, as our straight manly friends found out shortly after- he just smiled..... and then proceeded to demolish all three in about five seconds flat -funniest thing I ever saw.

They should send him to Afghanistan, think he could wipe out half the Taleban single-handedly :-))


By the way, in 2010, it seems wrong to call them "stereotypes". That term is too neutral.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Blackness at Blackwater

The good Christian men at Blackwater were ripping off Uncle Sam and making jokes about it in the paperwork, too.

As Rumsfeld said, you go to war with the contractors that you have to pay. (He didn't say that?)

All part of the above-the-law culture cultivated by Bush-Cheney? Who can say.

Latest on DADT, in the trenches...

Just heard this on talk radio: "Mothers in combat boots".

These are the fears pre-possessing some, apparently.

[As an aside, I wonder how that makes the Fatherless America folks feel?]

Just watching, now...

I don't think Andrew is going to get himself out of this one, alone, especially if he starts of with something so smug as this. The only compelling thing he's written lately is that Netanyahu and his government represent a tone that is at times shocking, arrogant and counterproductive in many dimensions.

Should that be surprising to Andrew's readers? It's not to me. If it is to Andrew, he doesn't know much about the rise of rightwing politics in Israel, maybe? Or, the willingness of some Israelis to stand up, even thumb their nose, at the U.S.? Is America so much better? Britain? France? All of them less prone to periods of irrationality in their foreign policies or otherwise, today or in yesteryear?

The same goes for the Gaza assessment. What about the 34 Days (or 33 days?)? What about any of the 'quiet aggressions' or other failings, recognized internally or not? Indeed, an "awakening" over Gaza may - may - say more about the writer than an objectively assessed change in the situation.

I suspect that Obama's low rating in Israel is the result of his (liberal? Jewish?) advisers, who put him on a course of opening relations with a demand to end to all settlement activity. Okay, now, even Rabin did not agree to that. That Rabin didn't alone should be an indication that (a) there is something not complete in this demand, as simple as it seems, or (b) Obama's advisers are just stupid, so much so that 90% of the Israeli public - or whatever large percent - now thinks that the U.S. President just doesn't "get it" in one way or another. To conflate this public opinion with a rightward shift of that magnitude in Israeli politics is absurd - Bibi doesn't enjoy nearly that much support. [Update: I'm reminded that the Roadmap does, in fact, call for an end to all settlement activity. All the more reason to appreciate how far off the road we are in terms of a peace framework, even a non-robust one like the Roadmap.]

"The defense of the Jewish people in the wake of the Holocaust" is tottering in the other direction, so the next salvo might come from angry Arabs... What's more, it's not a principle that is going to push the peace process along, even if it might be laudable on face.

It's not clear what settlement activity Andrew is referencing. Is he talking about the settlements that Israel recognizes as illegal? Or, is he referencing all the settlement activity that the Palestinians claim are illegal?

As for parts of the smear not coming from the unthinking or the fettered, it would do to be patient (and to wear a flak jacket, frankly). Hopefully, Andrew can realize that some folks can feel hurt by attacks on what they think are justified actions, even if Andrew doesn't think they are justified. They have passionate beliefs, too, and it is often easy to smear, rather than to educate. That's one reason why I don't like to read Leon. His rants don't educate anyone, so much. One learns more from Judt, for example, with whom I've found disagreement, even.

Palm Center Sets Standard for Congress

WHY WAIT FOR RAND?

I just e-mailed the new Palm Center report to my congresscritters and asked them to forward it to any of their colleagues known to be on the fence about repealing DADT pronto.

There is probably enough information on the table to repeal the law and leave the military to do just an implementation study, not a "what if" or "considerations" study.

There is much to quote, but this goes right to the core of the counter-arguments that I've heard voiced:



Those who support eliminating “don’t ask, don’t tell” acknowledge that important differences distinguish the U.S. military from other armed forces, but suggest that the relevant question is not whether differences exist, but whether they render foreign military experiences irrelevant for determining whether military effectiveness would decline if gays and lesbians were allowed to serve openly in the U.S.

Indeed, scholars have already explained why such differences do not diminish the relevance of these lessons, but opponents of gays in the military have not responded.[309]

Rather, they robotically repeat the point that the U.S. military cannot be compared to or learn from the experiences of other militaries.

In short, although the U.S. has more international obligations than other countries and its culture is unique, the question is not how similar our missions or culture are to those of other nations but whether the United States is any less capable than other nations of integrating gays into its military.


I concur.

Indeed, the entire 'study period' seems to be designed to convince the military leadership that they are up to the task, not to really "study" the issue. That's a goal, too.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Surreal - Surreal

We now have embeds with 'the enemy'. PBS has footage of a guy, an Afghani journalist, who went along with a group who set IED on the Northern route in Afghanistan. This is way beyond the scary "re-education tours" often given to journalists who don't provide the right view.

I could be wrong, but, during a conflict, I don't think I've seen anything like it, ever. Did we ever get footage from the Viet Cong, for instance? This is not homemade propaganda video of successful attacks. It's coverage of an entire enemy sortie, start to finish, complete with some individual interviews with members of the team and sketches of their backgrounds.


Banana Republic, II

Apparently, Senators just nod or something to give assent, no terms document or actions approved document. Maybe, all you have to do is lift a finger from the table?

Is this a manageable level of violence?

Is this level of violence low enough that the nation's "cohesion" isn't threatened?

What is the mood among Iraqis? Qien sabe?

The recent ban on a long list of politicians, is that a good thing? Have we created a mister or a monster?

News from "Cambodia"

The roll-up of the network in Pakistan appears to have a little momentum. The information flow between the U.S. and Pakistan is dicey. This latest capture is reported to have been done by ISI alone (so much for the new era of trust, but one doesn't look a gift horse in the mouth):

The capture of Mullah Kabir appeared to be a strictly Pakistani operation, and Pakistani officials appeared to be keeping Mullah Kabir’s arrest a closely held secret, even from their American allies.

Mullah Kabir is a longtime associate of Mullah Omar, the Taliban’s founder. He was the governor of Nangarhar Province, in eastern Afghanistan, when the Taliban ruled Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001. Since then, he has overseen military operations in eastern Afghanistan, including those in Kunar, Nangarhar, Nuristan and Laghman Provinces.

The immediate impact of Mullah Kabir’s arrest remains to be seen. The Quetta Shura is thought to have roughly 20 people. A number have been killed or captured over the years, but the shura, and the Taliban, have gone on.


All the kings horses and all the king's men are looking for 20 people, in the haystack that is Quetta.

Monday, February 22, 2010

Banana Republic versus Banana Republicans

David Luben outlines how taxpayers paid to have a big study that confirms the dividing line between a few banana Republicans and ... how there is no line to cross, leaving the bare fact that we are technically, professional, legally a Banana Republic, right?

We look down our noses, say, at Chavez. Technically, he just has a different legal opinion.

A horse can work at the OLC


TORTURE IS NOT OVER IN AMERICA - WE COULD TORTURE AGAIN

It's true: It's easier to get a charge as a disorderly person than for a dishonest analysis at the OLC.

I have a different question for those closer to the legal battle over what was done: of course, it could happen again, right? (n.b. Fallows, who thinks it is in the past).

As I see it, all President Palin would have to do is to replace the OLC with "friendlies", even well meaning "extremists" with Federalist Society credentials, intimate comfortable judgeships for cooperating attorneys, and have the "aging" opinions "updated", especially if there was an explosion near Capital Hill or wherever that "changed everything".

So far as I can tell, Obama has instituted* new policy and new practice; but those could change in a new administration.

Congress, so far as I'm aware, hasn't clarified anything binding. Indeed, the same snow-them-under techniques are still available to a wily Executive, with the possible exception that someone's ears might perk up at the term "waterboarding". The Detainee Act came with a very clear signing statement, asserting an Executive right to both interpret the act and to exercise Executive authority in defense of the nation.

The new attorney general, perhaps bowing to his boss, hasn't even tried to prosecute those who might be responsible (winning the verdict is not the point - "seek justice").

And, now, the lawyers who would write such an opinion can be assured that it might be "deplorable" to some, but it wouldn't bring them professional sanction. Seriously, if you can get away with torture, then what's left not to try, including trying it again?


-----
*technically, the Bush administration itself stopped some of the practices

The Reservoir of Trust

Tom Ricks is right. Read Yon about Adam Ray.
It's hard to believe that Yon has been eyes-and-ears for six years now.
14 MONTHS UNTIL DRAWDOWN

So, after six years of blundering ahead in Afghanistan under Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld-Rice, one has to ask the impenetrable question:

Is the reservoir of trust remaining among the public sufficient for this newest campaign, our next Great Leap Forward, at the fantastic price in blood and treasure that we are paying for it?

Tom Ricks just recently outlined some fancy metrics for success, as given by the Brian Trust.

However, with three mini buses of civilians bombed, one wonders how the chaos can end, once started. This is not Iraq. The Afghani people are not as educated and their 'common history' as a nation is far behind them (lost since the early 1980s, probably).

We don't have access to the metrics the military is tracking but, broad brush, back-of-the-envelop:

  • -The Danes are leaving, after two extensions of their commitment(s).
  • -The Afghan army is "behind"
  • -The all-important attitudes among populace are ... its impossible to generalize (McChrystal is hopeful, but tangible evidence of progress is hard to come by).
  • -The government got barely half its proposed cabinet members approved
  • -We now have a wider footprint than ever to defend (with logistics and logistical costs that are staggering)
  • -Iraq is pasted together (Petreaus has invented "Iraq-cracy" to describe their governance) to the point that it is still not clear if we can be 100% confident that drawdown is "correct".
  • -There are 14 months left on the 'original timetable' for the Afghan double-down.


  • -We've made progress in Pakistan, at the cost of sharing prized technology and many killed, on both sides
  • -Despite progress against Taliban, no one seems to have a clear idea whether their resources or willingness is finite
  • -One-eyed Omar is still at large

Palm Center Releases 1400 Word Paragraph

According to the NYT, the Palm Center will release a "primer" on integration of gays and lesbians in foreign militaries.

I visited the Palm website, missing the fact that the report will come out tomorrow. Amidst a snappy website (way beyond and above its predecessor incarnation, for those who remember it), I was confronted by a nearly 1400 word paragraph in a "press release", outlining key recommendations to the Pentagon's panel review.

Readers will know that The Spit Shine is not one to nitpick. But, it's time for the A-game on this.

Update: Fixed. Palm Center really are tops. (On reflection, I should have sent an e-mail, rather than write this note.)

Sunday, February 21, 2010

DADT - General Petreaus

I braved an interview by David Gregory to listen to General David Petreaus.

The message:

The military has a process. Trust the process, which will divorce individual opinion from institutional approach (for lack of a better term), and don't get the military too politicized on the emotions surrounding the topic.

This is sensible in terms of policy implementation. There is nothing sensible about the political process, however. Disagreements within the military will be amplified. Is it too much to hope for, in terms of a univocal recommendation from the brass? Probably.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Talk Radio - The 'We Can't Get Along' Meme

Gays won't let you be a good Christian.

Just caught a snippet on talk radio. The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence will defend the indefensible. Some chapel on base on North Carolina won't hang a cross.

These are the things keeping all Christians from their good works on earth.

This message is going out over and over, so it seems. It's the basis of the next iteration of homo put-down action, as likely as any other.

Clouded in desperation not to be a victim

I doubt that all political violence is "terrorism".

It does seem, however, if you admit a category of crime/criminal called "terrorism"/terrorist, because it is crime that is "politically motivated", then you really do have to admit a category of crime called, loosely, "hate crime".

There is no conceptual way around it. One cannot simply not draw a distinction where one can be made. So much is a logical distinction, neither conservative nor a-conservative.

Someone should tell Andrew Sullivan who is intensely thick on the topic, even to this day.

The fact that there are certain categories and characteristics that inform the penalty phase of the law seems to be commonsense, not specious reasoning. In fact, the obvious choice of these characteristics is precisely the kind of appeal to practical reason that really cuts across both progressive and conservative political conceits.

The Rightwing Will Turn Your Children into War Criminals

NOT an overstatement.

From the sidebar at the website Townhall.com, comes this "Hitler Youth" t-shirt: